Blog RSSBlog.


Big brother is a health care provider

Big brother may be watching you — no, not the one you’re thinking of, but one a lot closer to you: your local hospital or health care system.

Some hospital systems are now obtaining credit card transaction data about local populations, plugging the data into algorithms that identify those people most likely to get sick, then trying to intervene to prevent them from getting sick or having to go to an emergency department.

Some examples of data they might find useful: whether you have a gym membership, whether you shop at plus-sized stores, whether you buy cigarettes, whether you own a car, how many people live in your home, your food shopping and dining-out habits, your annual income.

Of course, marketers have been using such data for years to try to sell us things. The hospitals systems’ use of data is, at least ostensibly, for a higher purpose: as we move towards a medical system that pays providers for meeting quality benchmarks and penalizes them for not meeting certain quality benchmarks, it is not only in patients’ interests but in health care providers’ financial interest to intervene early and try to prevent people from having expensive complications.┬áBut something feels not-quite-right about hospitals using the same tactics Wal-Mart or Amazon uses.

I suppose this development is reflective of many current trends: the disappearance of privacy in our connected world, the medicalization of all of life, the development of the “Brave New Biocracy” of which Ivan Illich wrote, the shift in emphasis from individual to population health, the computer generation’s fascination with data (to a person with a hammer, everything looks like a nail; to a person with a computer, everyone looks like data), the skyrocketing costs of techno-medicine, and our elevation of health care to the highest good, before which all other considerations fade.

Our conviction that better health care is an absolute good means that when it comes to anything that looks like it could make health care better — whether it be inserting computer screens between doctors and patients, cloning humans and then destroying them to benefit other humans, or prying Big Brother-like into the intimate details of our lives to find ways we are not conforming to the latest dogma about what’s good for us — we ask, Can we? but never get around to the more important questions: Should we? And if we do, where might this lead?

This entry was posted in Health Care, Privacy and tagged , , , . Posted by Joe Gibes. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.