This article proposes a recontextualization of the conception of free will in terms of social events rather than in mental experiences. My objective is to demonstrate that the behavior of human social groups composed of individuals freely interacting among each other exhibits well-defined patterns that can precisely be described by a physics formalism. Although not directly approaching the nature of the mental states involved in each individual behavior, I argue that the emergence of organized social behavior occurs under the influence of free will. First, I briefly introduce the concept of self-organized criticality (SOC) that is central to the understanding of my argument. Second, I review experimental data showing that normal individuals and patients with different mental disorders exhibit a social behavior pattern compatible with the presence of SOC. Third, a brief discussion about the functioning of free will in psychiatric disorders is presented. Finally, the implications for psychological and social theories of including free will in this kind of physical model are discussed.
Open Peer Commentaries.
- Self-Organization as Conceptual Key to Understanding Free Will
- Which Came First, the Chicken or the Egg? Rethinking Causal Directions Between Neural Mechanisms, Agency, and Human Enhancement
- Neurobiology Is Not Destiny
- Toward A New Model of Autonomy: Lessons From Neuroscience
- Self-Reflexivity in the Formulation of Autonomy: An Appeal from Feminist Cultural Studies
- Autonomy Beyond the Brain: What Neuroscience Offers to a More Interactive, Relational Bioethics
- Full Autonomy, Substantial Autonomy, and Neuroscience
- Working While Under the Influence of Performance-Enhancing Drugs: Is One “More Responsible”?
- Is Diminished Free Will Legally Relevant and Is Enhanced Free Will Possible?
- Emotions, Autonomy, and Decision-Making Capacity
- Emotionality and Competence: Changing Emotions Versus Dealing With Emotions
- The Place of Emotions in Capacity Assessments
- Examining the “Neuro-” in Neurodiversity: Lessons from Body Integrity Identity Disorder
- Biophysical Models of Human Behavior: Is There A Place for Logic?