Get Published | Subscribe | About | Write for Our Blog    

American Journal of Bioethics.

Filthy Lucre or Fitting Offer? Understanding Worries About Payments to Research Participants

Offers of payment made in exchange for research participation are common. And yet they are often regarded as, at best, a “necessary evil.” This is odd. In most nonresearch contexts, people find payment for goods and services unproblematic. Indeed, when goods and services are not intended as gifts, failure to pay for them is a problem; we call it theft. Why should payments made in the context of research participation be of particular ethical concern?

The target articles in this issue of AJOB point to two novel responses: research participation as unfulfilling work and coercion as subjection. The authors suggest that their concerns can be addressed by offering higher payments for research participation, an outcome we agree with. However, we do not share their ethical worries. It is ethically unproblematic for research participants not to share the goals of research, to be motivated to participate because they lack better options, and to view participation as work, even if it is unsatisfying.

View Full Text

Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.

Volume 19, Issue 9
September 2019

Editorial.

Filthy Lucre or Fitting Offer? Understanding Worries About Payments to Research Participants Emily A. Largent, Ezekiel J. Emanuel & Holly Fernandez Lynch
Why Dax’s Case Still Matters Kayhan Parsi & William J. Winslade