by Ann Mongoven, Ph.D., MPH
All hearts go out to the Gard family in this time of grief for their son, Charlie.
The legal wrangling over Charlie’s care became a political football–unfortunately, about many things having little to do with Charlie.
Despite the involvement of Pope Francis, this was not a case about abortion rights or the sanctity of human life. Catholic tradition warns both that quality-of-life arguments can dehumanize the disabled, and that unduly burdensome medical care can become assaultive. There is no “Catholic” view of the case, and Catholic moral theologians disagree about it.
Despite the involvement of Donald Trump, this was not a case about the relative merits of the U.K.…